Initiating
Portfolios in Your School
Case Study #1
Case One School is a
small rural school of 150 students with limited technology. There is no
kindergarten in the district. The school houses grades 1 through
8. There is one class at each grade level. Our kids go to a regional high
school. The school has dialup Internet connections that are not very
reliable. The district does not have a technology integrator. While
each classroom does have a computer, there is no computer lab. There are
6 computers in the library. The library media specialist is the technology
leader in the school. The school board supports the initiative but has limited
funds to commit to technology upgrade in the school.
Table of Contents
1 Purpose
2 Curriculum
3 Requirements
4 Reviewer
5 Assessment
6 Organization
7 Storage
8 Implementation
This
case study was contributed by the following
ICT
Summer Institute 2006 participants:
Vicky
Bridge, Jocelyne Kauffman, Jerry LaChance,
San Murray, Shannon Poehlman, Carla Press, Nancy Webster
1 Establish the
purpose for the portfolio based on your district’s goals and mission.
What do you think the purpose of the
portfolio should be?
The purpose of the 1-8 ICT electronic
portfolio is to document students' proficiency of New Hampshire Information and
Communication Technology Standards. This portfolio will demonstrate an
integrated approach of NHICT standards within all Case
One School District's
content area curricula. The portfolio is a dynamic document reflecting growth
and informing instruction.
All students in Case One
School will create a digital
portfolio that shows their understanding of the application of technology in
core subjects. Portfolio contents can help the teacher determine future
instruction and showcase student work in content areas. (Student projects that
are placed in the portfolio will be called artifacts.)
What type of Portfolio would you like to
create?
In grades 1-7 the portfolio will
be used for formative assessment. In grade 8 the cumulative portfolio
will be reviewed for summative assessment.
In grades 1-7 the portfolio will be used to assist the teacher in
planning further instruction (formative assessment is used to plan
instruction; also known as for instruction). In grade 8 the
cumulative portfolio will be assessed to determine competency (summative
assessment measures student competency in comparison to a norm; also known as of
instruction.)
Glossary:
DEFINITIONS
Artifacts
Documents and other work samples that
the owner of the portfolio uses to demonstrate the attainment of the knowledge,
skills, or disposition necessary to meet a standard or address the essential
question of the portfolio.
Dispositions
“The values, commitments, and professional ethics that
influence behaviors toward students, families, colleagues, and communities and
affect student learning, motivation, and development as well as the educator's
own professional growth. Dispositions are guided by beliefs and attitudes
related to values such as caring, fairness, honesty, responsibility, and social
justice. For example, they might include a belief that all students can learn,
a vision of high and challenging standards, or a commitment to a safe and
supportive learning environment” (NCATE, 2000).
Knowledge
Refers to the candidate's understanding of childhood
studies, based on “empirical research, disciplined inquiry, informed theory,
and the wisdom of practice” (NCATE, 2000).
Owner
The creator of the portfolio.
Portfolio
Refers to “a purposeful collection of student work that
exhibits the student's efforts, progress, and achievements in one or more areas
of the curriculum” (Paulsen, Paulsen, and Meyer, 1991, p. 10).
Professional Growth Portfolio
Built and maintained during the undergraduate experience
at PSU; artifacts and reflections, illustrating a range of completeness, are
intended to show development, change, and growth.
Presentation Portfolio
Completed at the end of a
program, and intended to contain artifacts that are complete and of “best
work” quality.
Reviewer
Anyone, inside or outside of the
institution, who has been granted permission to see the portfolio. In
many cases, reviewers will be faculty members and advisees; however, clinical
faculty, cooperating teachers, and potential employers are, by definition,
considered reviewers.
Reflection
Refers to the “contemplation and consideration regarding
the significance of an event or artifact; evaluation of the value and meaning
of the event or artifact as it relates to a larger context” (Nonprofit Basics,
2004, p.1).
Self-Rate
Refers to whenever a portfolio owner uses the same
assessment tool as a reviewer to gauge the quality of the portfolio intent,
content, or design.
Skills
The ability to apply content,
pedagogical, personal, and professional knowledge competently.
Thanks
to Plymouth State University and Royce Robertson for letting us use
and amend their list of terms.
PowerPoint
Assessment Portfolio Example
(This
link goes to a Powerpoint file on the web.)
2 Determine how
existing school or district curriculum aligns with the ICT standards.
How does your current curriculum align
with the ICT standards required for the portfolio?
The following tool was adapted using
the resources found at NHDOE, Office of Ed Tech -
http://www.nheon.org/ictliteracy/
Developing
K-8 Portfolio Requirements
All classroom teachers, in
collaboration with the Library Media Specialist, will complete the following
table to determine what we already do in our school that can be used to
generate artifacts for evidence of meeting competencies.
New Hampshire ICT Literacy Standards
Step 1:
Start with Existing Curriculum
Based on your knowledge of your district and school(s),
are there certain ICT tools and functions used in certain content areas
at certain grade levels that come to mind? Identifying them will help in
planning likely places to start working with students to gather portfolio
artifacts to be used for assessment. Make a list of at least 6 areas to start
with:
|
Grade
|
Lesson Activity
|
Tools & Functions Used
|
Possible Artifacts
|
ICT Components
|
|
Reading
|
|
|
|
Basic operations and concepts;
Social, ethical, and
human issues;
Technology
productivity tools;
Technology
communications tools;
Technology research
tools; and
Technology problem
solving and decision-making tools
|
|
English & Language
Arts
|
|
|
|
Basic operations and concepts;
Social, ethical, and
human issues;
Technology productivity tools;
Technology communications tools;
Technology research tools; and
Technology problem solving and decision-making
tools
|
|
Math
|
|
|
|
Basic operations and concepts;
Social, ethical, and human issues;
Technology productivity tools;
Technology communications tools;
Technology research tools; and
Technology problem solving and decision-making
tools
|
|
Science
|
|
|
|
Basic operations and concepts;
Social, ethical, and human issues;
Technology productivity tools;
Technology communications tools;
Technology research tools; and
Technology problem solving and decision-making
tools
|
|
Social Studies
|
|
|
|
Basic operations and concepts;
Social, ethical, and human issues;
Technology productivity tools;
Technology communications tools;
Technology research tools; and
Technology problem solving and decision-making
tools
|
|
Arts
|
|
|
|
Basic operations and concepts;
Social, ethical, and human issues;
Technology productivity tools;
Technology communications tools;
Technology research tools; and
Technology problem solving and decision-making
tools
|
|
World Languages
|
|
|
|
Basic operations and concepts;
Social, ethical, and human issues;
Technology productivity tools;
Technology communications tools;
Technology research tools; and
Technology problem solving and decision-making
tools
|
Step 2: Determine and record the ICT standards that are not addressed.
Step 3: Determine how standards will be met.
3 Determine the
content requirements that will be placed in the portfolio.
What content requirements does your
school want in the portfolio?
New Hampshire ICT Literacy Standards
Consider
the following elements when developing an Assessment Rubric for 8th Grade
Digital Portfolios:
|
CORE
SUBJECT
(Check
one)
|
Portfolio
Component
(For
each component below, decide what artifacts and how many will be required for
each content area.)
|
Number
and Type of Artifacts Required
(Based
on your current district curricula)
|
What does
successful demonstration of knowledge, skill, and understanding of these
competencies at the end of 8th Grade look like? (This section should be expanded
at a future date into specific assessment rubrics to describe the mastery
levels your district will require for each type of artifact.)
|
|
Tests
|
Observations
|
Student Work
|
Student Reflect
|
Other
|
|
□ Reading
□ Eng/LA
□ Math
□ Science
□ Social Studies
□ Arts
□ World Languages
|
Basic operations and concepts
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Social, ethical, and human
issues
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Productivity tools
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Communication tools
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Research tools
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Problem solving and decision
making tools
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Total
Artifacts for Core Subject:
(Minimum
**)
|
|
|
|
|
|
How many artifacts are necessary and
adequate?
**The number of artifacts in
cumulative portfolio will reflect all core subjects and cognitive proficiencies
and must include student and teacher reflection.
*In the grade 8 summative portfolios a reflection document
on the portfolio process will be required. Using the portfolio template the
student will link a minimum of six (6) artifacts, with reflections,
demonstrating ICT competencies. Artifacts may cross core curricula.
*The grade 1 - 7 formative portfolios should
contain at least one artifact (with reflection) per subject area per grade or a
cumulative project with reflection covering multiple core subjects (with
reflection). The competencies checklist will live in the student's portfolio
folder and be used by teachers to facilitate formative learning experiences
enhancing individualized student progress.
4 Determine the
reviewer process for assessing the portfolios.
Who will review the portfolios and how
will the assessment be done?
In grades 1-7 artifacts should represent core
curricular components and involve interactive assessment by student and teacher
before inclusion in portfolio. Media Specialist will collaborate with
content teacher to coordinate use of resources. Temporary ICT server will be
maintained in Library.
Students in
grades 1 through 7 will store work in designated folders on the ICT
server. When an artifact is chosen to go into the portfolio, the student
and teacher will each use the appropriate rubrics and checklists for reflection
purposes. Early grades (1-2) will use a simple checklist. As the
student progresses through the grades, the reflection process will become more
comprehensive. Reflections are required as support documents when
artifacts are added to the folder.
|
CORE
SUBJECT
(Check
one)
|
Portfolio
Component
(Check
one)
|
Artifact
Reflection
Title of Artifact:
Reflection Date:
|
|
|
Student
Reflection:
|
|
|
□
Reading
□
Eng/LA
□
Math
□
Science
□
Social
Studies
□
Arts
□
World
Languages
|
□
Basic
operations and concepts
|
|
|
□
Social,
ethical, and human issues
|
|
|
□
Productivity
tools
|
|
|